Saturday, May 25th

Last update11:44:07 PM

Building and owning your Swing Group Forum: Since we all had to start somewhere. I would like to start a group, where all can share their humle beginnings and the path that has lead them to where they are now.

From the first shot to the one that got you hooked. From frustration to triumph. From student to teacher, we all have one thing in common, we all love golf. Personally,1lovegolf.

So with humility, grace,and perciverance, we all have traveled the path to understanding our swing with hopes of owning it.

This group and threads will be dedicated to stories about where we were, where we are and where we want to go. There is no ending, only the journey and those we wish to share it with.

TOPIC: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30351

Tapio Santala wrote:



I know even the reason why he is here and you will find it out in one or two weeks. I tell you then.




Why wait, Tapio? I came here to burst your balloon! Off to a pretty good start, I'd say!

How was your sleep last night?




Jeff

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30352

  • Drew Art
  • OFFLINE
  • Platinum Boarder
  • Posts: 1645
phily wrote:
oh well.
----------------------------------


Drew, SVSV,

Is this Larry Mowry on the right ?



Yes, sir!

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30353

  • phily
  • OFFLINE
  • Platinum Boarder
  • Posts: 766
I started this cartoon earlier, wished I hadn't, but here's at least what I was going for.

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30354

  • phily
  • OFFLINE
  • Platinum Boarder
  • Posts: 766
Jeff, .. you mentioned working with Kelvin Miyahira, anything interesting you are currently working on right now that you can share?

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30355

  • phily
  • OFFLINE
  • Platinum Boarder
  • Posts: 766
Drew Art wrote:
phily wrote:
oh well.
----------------------------------


Drew, SVSV,

Is this Larry Mowry on the right ?



Yes, sir!


Hi Drew -
What's the significance of the 'be red' label in the photo ?

EDIT - oh for ƒ*** sake, I just realized it's 'bs' not 'be'.
I had even enlarged the photo and thought it clearly read 'be red'. ("Be the ball Danny").
Time for some sleep.
Last Edit: 1 year, 1 month ago by phily.

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30356

  • Steve P
  • OFFLINE
  • Platinum Boarder
  • Posts: 826
Jeff Martin wrote:
Steve P wrote:
If Bubba is Picasso than Hogan is Einstein. One way the genius emerges without rules in the second the genius emerges through application of rules.

You can't teach what Bubbas got but you could teach someone to be like Hogan he never did nuthin without reason.



Rubbish! It is easier to swing like Bubba than Hogan! Two concrete examples.


Hogan used a weak grip with both hands. What other great golfer used a weak grip in both hands? Johnny Miller, if you consider two majors great. Nobody else. Bubba uses a strong grip, by far the grip of choice on tour, and one that is much easier to deliver a square clubface at impact.

Hogan's backswing was flat and he got his arms a little behind him. As a result, he had to work like a demon to get his arms back in front of him in the downswing. Ever watch his "concentration drills" where he forces the right elbow deep in front of his chest? He never stopped working on that: he's still doing it in George Coleman's backyard in 1978!!!



In fact, post-accident, because of his weakened hip turn, Hogan couldn't get his right elbow where it was pre-accident:







A higher arm swing, like Bubba's makes that move easier to execute, as Kelvin explains in this video:



Both Hogan and Bubba were/are fantastic athletes, but Larry Mowry posted years ago at the Plane Truth site asking why everyone was obsessing over Hogan when Tiger Woods had a superior swing that was easier to learn. Well, now there is a new sheriff in town, and his name is Bubba.







Jeff



It IS easier to look like Bubba when you swing you're correct. I doubt your ballflight would resemble his however. That man has great great hands.

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30357

phily wrote:
Jeff, .. you mentioned working with Kelvin Miyahira, anything interesting you are currently working on right now that you can share?



Sure.

The big things to learn are the spine movements in transition and the downswing (lumbar lordosis and lateral bend), right elbow move (right shoulder external rotation and right arm transverse adduction), and leg movement in the downswing (the "squat" with good left hip external rotation, then a nice firing of the "fearsome foursome": the hips adductors and glutes). For the first time ever, yesterday, I think I finally understood how the legs and hips fire. Unfortunately, I seem to have "disabled" my flash card, so I have nothing to post, but, for the first time this season, my right lower back is pain free. Pretty exciting for this old codger!



Jeff

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30358

Drew Art wrote:
SVSV, sorry. I did not realize that was private. Tell me what you want to be called and I will call you only that.

I'm glad you are back. You have put a lot of time and study in on the mechanics, and I enjoy your substantive posts and it was super cool to see how you helped Grady. Really cool.

Once again, i would encourage you to condense your thoughts and start a thread with them. I think the forum would benefit from that, and i think it would be great to start over with a fresh canvas. You should not be afraid to that.


Don't worry about it.

Not interested in separate thread. Just want to talk about Hogan stuff, learn further, improve on it. Can't see why the need for separate thread, except to dis-associate my discussions on Ben Hogan's swing and get me away from here.

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30360

phily wrote:
Jeff, .. you mentioned working with Kelvin Miyahira, anything interesting you are currently working on right now that you can share?



Also, flattening the left wrist in the downswing (cupped to bowed), including a bit of early supination, but not a lot since I'm also working on a strong grip. Also want to get my arms and right elbow higher in the backswing (trying to shed all of the Jim Hardy one-plane nonsense once and for all).




Jeff

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30361

phily wrote:
I started this cartoon earlier, wished I hadn't, but here's at least what I was going for.




Go, DJ! Great right elbow move, one of the best. Perhaps the best ballstriker on tour last year.




Jeff

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30362

Martin Ayers wrote:



lmao.







Yeah, me, too.









Jeff
Last Edit: 1 year, 1 month ago by Jeff Martin.

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30363

Jeff Martin wrote:
phily wrote:
Jeff, .. you mentioned working with Kelvin Miyahira, anything interesting you are currently working on right now that you can share?



Also, flattening the left wrist in the downswing (cupped to bowed), including a bit of early supination, but not a lot since I'm also working on a strong grip. Also want to get my arms and right elbow higher in the backswing (trying to shed all of the Jim Hardy one-plane nonsense once and for all).




Jeff


Jeffy, can you define that early supination?

I mean at what moment of swing it happens and about how many degrees you left forearm is rotating relative to the upper arm at that moment? Thanks.

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30364

Jeff Martin wrote:
Steve P wrote:
If Bubba is Picasso than Hogan is Einstein. One way the genius emerges without rules in the second the genius emerges through application of rules.

You can't teach what Bubbas got but you could teach someone to be like Hogan he never did nuthin without reason.



Rubbish! It is easier to swing like Bubba than Hogan! Two concrete examples.


Hogan used a weak grip with both hands. What other great golfer used a weak grip in both hands? Johnny Miller, if you consider two majors great. Nobody else. Bubba uses a strong grip, by far the grip of choice on tour, and one that is much easier to deliver a square clubface at impact.

Hogan's backswing was flat and he got his arms a little behind him. As a result, he had to work like a demon to get his arms back in front of him in the downswing. Ever watch his "concentration drills" where he forces the right elbow deep in front of his chest? He never stopped working on that: he's still doing it in George Coleman's backyard in 1978!!!



In fact, post-accident, because of his weakened hip turn, Hogan couldn't get his right elbow where it was pre-accident:







A higher arm swing, like Bubba's makes that move easier to execute, as Kelvin explains in this video:



Both Hogan and Bubba were/are fantastic athletes, but Larry Mowry posted years ago at the Plane Truth site asking why everyone was obsessing over Hogan when Tiger Woods had a superior swing that was easier to learn. Well, now there is a new sheriff in town, and his name is Bubba.







Jeff


Hogan did what Bubba is doing without disconnecting his upper arms from his armpits/chest. Explains why Hogan is more consistent.

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30365

benbubba1.jpg


HoganBubba1.jpg
The following user(s) said Thank You: Tapio Santala

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30366

Jeff Martin wrote:
Grady Dickens wrote:
Jeff,

There are left foots that move around...and there are left foots that move around. If the left heel gets off the ground...BAD...if the foot toe comes a bit off the ground and forces work left and back...FINE.




Then that makes me Bubba BAD!!!!




Jeff


Bubba, just like yours, lifts his left heel because he doesn't get his hip center forward or targetwards enough, which is needed to free up the L hip. If he doesn't, he will injure or cause pain in his inside L hip muscles/tendons. That lifting of L heel move also is needed to make his baseline/path more inline (less out to in) and to shallow it out big time. Actually, ultimate cause is that too upright L arm swing of his coupled with a lack of and early enough lateral movement of the L hip (which Nicklaus did so perfectly, by the way; no, Nicklaus didn't lift his L heel). Bubba, as I see it, just turns the heck out of his hips without much lateral (as I said unlike Nicklaus). If Bubba (or you, for that matter) doesn't lift your L heel, you will end up like an old man crouching over towards the target in the finish, unless of course you stop turning your shoulders/torso, which in this case will cause Bubba/you to finish on your R foot.
Last Edit: 1 year, 1 month ago by svsvincenzo.

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30367

Jeff Martin wrote:
Steve P wrote:
If Bubba is Picasso than Hogan is Einstein. One way the genius emerges without rules in the second the genius emerges through application of rules.

You can't teach what Bubbas got but you could teach someone to be like Hogan he never did nuthin without reason.



Rubbish! It is easier to swing like Bubba than Hogan! Two concrete examples.


Hogan used a weak grip with both hands. What other great golfer used a weak grip in both hands? Johnny Miller, if you consider two majors great. Nobody else. Bubba uses a strong grip, by far the grip of choice on tour, and one that is much easier to deliver a square clubface at impact.

Hogan's backswing was flat and he got his arms a little behind him. As a result, he had to work like a demon to get his arms back in front of him in the downswing. Ever watch his "concentration drills" where he forces the right elbow deep in front of his chest? He never stopped working on that: he's still doing it in George Coleman's backyard in 1978!!!



In fact, post-accident, because of his weakened hip turn, Hogan couldn't get his right elbow where it was pre-accident:







A higher arm swing, like Bubba's makes that move easier to execute, as Kelvin explains in this video:



Both Hogan and Bubba were/are fantastic athletes, but Larry Mowry posted years ago at the Plane Truth site asking why everyone was obsessing over Hogan when Tiger Woods had a superior swing that was easier to learn. Well, now there is a new sheriff in town, and his name is Bubba.







Jeff


Can't agree with your statement that Hogan swung flat. He swung upright on that plane of glass of his. And if you consider his shorter height and longer arms, you would realize how upright it is. It's just that his L arm swung flat relative to his shoulders, especially L shoulder.

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30368

[quote="Stephen Vicente S. Vincenzo" post=30367][
Can't agree with your statement that Hogan swung flat. He swung upright on that plane of glass of his. And if you consider his shorter height and longer arms, you would realize how upright it is. It's just that his L arm swung flat relative to his shoulders, especially L shoulder.[/quote]


He couldn't be flatter or more around him.

http://teeace.kapsi.fi/hogantop.jpeg
Last Edit: 1 year, 1 month ago by Tapio Santala.

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30369

Jeff Martin wrote:
Tapio Santala wrote:



I know even the reason why he is here and you will find it out in one or two weeks. I tell you then.




Why wait, Tapio? I came here to burst your balloon! Off to a pretty good start, I'd say!

How was your sleep last night?




Jeff

Not a great motivation for coming here......
Posting your over-rotated mess of a swing wasn't the best start....
The following user(s) said Thank You: Festus

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30370

[quote="Tapio Santala" post=30368]Stephen Vicente S. Vincenzo wrote:
[
Can't agree with your statement that Hogan swung flat. He swung upright on that plane of glass of his. And if you consider his shorter height and longer arms, you would realize how upright it is. It's just that his L arm swung flat relative to his shoulders, especially L shoulder.[/quote]


He couldn't be flatter or more around him.

http://teeace.kapsi.fi/hogantop.jpeg


Couldn't see the image.

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30371

I was enjoying reading this thread until Jeff turned up. I'll save myself the trouble of internet rage and step out until it becomes the friendly snipe free place it was before.
The following user(s) said Thank You: Burk McDuff

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30374

  • Festus
  • OFFLINE
  • Platinum Boarder
  • Posts: 1092
Jeff, you wrote:

However, I no plans to start planting my left heel and try to keep it stationary. Might look pretty, but it strips out athleticism.

Are you kidding? If not, says who?

Doesn't it simply reduce to how one is moving through space.

On a side note, I've only posted on 2 golf forums ( Advanced Ball Striking and SITD ) both having what I consider some fine professional minds walking the internet halls offering great insight and instruction. It continually amazes me, and is beyond description sometimes, when individuals, perhaps amateurs, with nowhere near the playing or practical ability seem to swat away comments from those that walk the halls like an irrelevant horsefly- or will make an absurd comment about Johnny Miller's career.

Just sayin'.....while biting my tongue.
Last Edit: 1 year, 1 month ago by Festus.
The following user(s) said Thank You: Burk McDuff

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30375

Seems like I'm not the only "old codger" that can't remember his potty training....

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30376

Martin Ayers wrote:
Jeff Martin wrote:
Tapio Santala wrote:



I know even the reason why he is here and you will find it out in one or two weeks. I tell you then.




Why wait, Tapio? I came here to burst your balloon! Off to a pretty good start, I'd say!

How was your sleep last night?




Jeff

Not a great motivation for coming here......
Posting your over-rotated mess of a swing wasn't the best start....



Well, nobody's perfect.


Someone asked to see my swing. It is what it is! Working on it!





Jeff

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30377

Festus wrote:
Jeff, you wrote:

However, I no plans to start planting my left heel and try to keep it stationary. Might look pretty, but it strips out athleticism.

Are you kidding? If not, says who?

Doesn't it simply reduce to how one is moving through space.

On a side note, I've only posted on 2 golf forums ( Advanced Ball Striking and SITD ) both having what I consider some fine professional minds walking the internet halls offering great insight and instruction. It continually amazes me, and is beyond description sometimes, when individuals, perhaps amateurs, with nowhere near the playing or practical ability seem to swat away comments from those that walk the halls like an irrelevant horsefly- or will make an absurd comment about Johnny Miller's career.

Just sayin'.....while biting my tongue.




It wasn't meant as an "absurd comment". I think Miller had a great career, and a fantastic swing, it is just that the internet is full of goal post movers that might easily say two majors and 25 tour wins really isn't great.

Sorry for the confusion.





Jeff

Re: Hogan's "Ultimate" Secret 1 year, 1 month ago #30378

Stephen Vicente S. Vincenzo wrote:
Jeff Martin wrote:
Grady Dickens wrote:
Jeff,

There are left foots that move around...and there are left foots that move around. If the left heel gets off the ground...BAD...if the foot toe comes a bit off the ground and forces work left and back...FINE.




Then that makes me Bubba BAD!!!!




Jeff


Bubba, just like yours, lifts his left heel because he doesn't get his hip center forward or targetwards enough, which is needed to free up the L hip. If he doesn't, he will injure or cause pain in his inside L hip muscles/tendons. That lifting of L heel move also is needed to make his baseline/path more inline (less out to in) and to shallow it out big time. Actually, ultimate cause is that too upright L arm swing of his coupled with a lack of and early enough lateral movement of the L hip (which Nicklaus did so perfectly, by the way; no, Nicklaus didn't lift his L heel). Bubba, as I see it, just turns the heck out of his hips without much lateral (as I said unlike Nicklaus). If Bubba (or you, for that matter) doesn't lift your L heel, you will end up like an old man crouching over towards the target in the finish, unless of course you stop turning your shoulders/torso, which in this case will cause Bubba/you to finish on your R foot.




I did an analysis of Nicklaus's hip movement that you might enjoy. In transition replanted his left heel from address and that created the illusion of a larger hip movement. The swing I looked at was from 1963, the period he said later in life when he swung the best.


jeffygolf.com/showthread.php?59-Jack-Nic...ow-big-was-it-really


Also, when he really busted it, his left foot float/rotated with the left heel pulling back towards him. See 0:16 in this video:





Don't have GIF software on my Mac, but this gives an idea:








Jeff
Time to create page: 0.88 seconds